The Pros and Cons of Common Milkweed

Common milkweed is good for monarch butterflies, but is it right for your garden?

With the declining population of monarchs in the news so often these days, many home gardeners are choosing to add milkweed to their butterfly gardens to help support this beautiful butterfly. This is a fantastic idea, and I encourage everyone to plant as much milkweed as they possibly can. But there are many species of milkweed, and it’s best to choose species that are both native to your area as well as appropriate for your garden space. Common Milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) has a wide native range and is easy to find, but it also has some aggressive properties that may not make it right for your butterfly garden.

Common Milkweed

Common Milkweed Range MapCommon milkweed can be found throughout most of the Eastern U.S. and Canada (with the exception of Florida), west to the Rocky Mountains. It grows in a variety of soil conditions, usually in full sun, and is often found in ditches and roadside medians. It can grow quickly to 5 feet tall, with broad leaves and a stout stem, topped by clusters of pink flowers that butterflies visit for nectar. The leaves are used by monarch caterpillars for food (milkweeds are their only food source) and are vital to the species’ survival. In the late summer, the flowers give way to large pods, which burst open to send their feathery-topped seeds into the wind to spread for the following year.

Who should grow Common Milkweed? Anyone in its native range (zones 3 – 8) with space for a wildflower garden can consider Common Milkweed. But gardeners should be aware that this species is considered very aggressive. It spreads not only by seed but by underground rhizome, and can be very difficult to control. If you have a large area available, or aren’t worried about the possibly “weedy” appearance of this plant, you should find a local source for some seeds and add it to your property.

If you have a small yard, are outside its native range, or have a latex allergy, you should think twice before planting Common Milkweed. (Common milkweed, like other milkweed species, contains latex, which causes its foliage to be very sticky and can lead to rashes in those allergic to latex.) Once established, it’s nearly impossible to get rid of. You can try growing it in sunken pots in the ground to limit the rhizome spread, and clipping the seed pods before they mature to stop the seeds from spreading. But it’s probably better to consider one of the many other species of milkweed native to your area. (Get more info here).

Common Milkweed

Jill Staake
Jill lives in Tampa, Florida, and writes about gardening, butterflies, outdoor projects and birding. When she's not gardening, you'll find her reading, traveling and happily digging her toes into the sand on the beach.