Best Seed Starting Tips From Our Community Members

Jill Staake

It’s that time of year: seed catalog time! Noelle offered a few of her favorites a couple of weeks ago, and I’ve been poring over mine as well. But I have to admit – starting seeds is something that I often find overwhelming. I’m mostly fond of wildflower seeds, which you can just fling into your garden and allow to do their own thing. But there are amazing varieties of flowers and veggies in catalogs that you won’t find for sale at your local nursery, so learning to start seeds is a valuable skill, and one that can keep you going in those dull winter months where the only gardening you would otherwise do is the occasional watering of the spider plant hanging in your kitchen window.

For the best tips for beginners, I went to the Gardening forum in the Birds & Blooms Community, and asked them what they would have wanted to know when they were getting started. They had plenty of answers to help even the most apprehensive seed-starting newbie, including a whole thread showing their various methods and setups. Here are some of their top tips.

Seed Starting

Seed packets offer plenty of tips. Be sure to follow their suggestions for light exposure and temperature.

Start out simple. Steve232_NC says, “start cheap and don’t try to do too much your first time.” Although the seed catalogs will be full of tempting offers, not all are good for first-timers. Community member Charlene (plantdoctorzn4) recommends, “Buy seeds that are rated for the beginner gardener. If you order from websites, many of them list beginner, intermediate, and advanced. Trying a seed that is too difficult for your ability will discourage you from ever starting any again.”

Start out right. You can start a lot of seeds in a small space, but make sure you know their requirements first. Charlene says, “Follow the package instructions on how to sow. Some seeds need light to germinate (that means to barely cover the seed, or not cover it at all) while others require dark….bury the seed, but not too deep!” The type of soil matters too, as Steve232_NC notes: “Be sure to use seed starting mix for planting your seeds. Later you can transplant them to your favorite potting soil.” Make things easier on yourself by investing in a seed-starting kit. I’ve had good luck in recent years with the somewhat pricey Park Seed Bio Dome kits, but there are plenty of inexpensive options available at nurseries and home improvement stores.

Seed Starting

Community member Charlene uses inexpensive seed starting kits, and has great success.

Provide light. One of the most important factors to deal with is how you will provide the light your seeds need to germinate and grow. Charlene advises, “Once the seed has germinated make sure that it receives 12 hrs of light daily – artificial light or direct light like a south window. If you do use a south window, it is necessary to turn them once daily because they start reaching for the light and get spindly it you dont.” For many, it’s easier to invest in some grow lights, available at your local nursery, and then improvise. Community member Gayle (cove2700) notes, “Doesn’t have to be an expensive set up. A lot of us started out with lights balanced across books or paint cans or whatever. You need to make sure that the seedlings are no more than a couple inches from the lights. too far away from the light & they will stretch for it & get spindly.” This was one of her first set-ups:

Seed Starting

This setup by Gayle (cove2700) is on top the of microwave cart in her kitchen.

Add water. The second important factor to consider is watering. Seeds and seedlings don’t do all that well with watering from the top. Linda Z (narnian) says, “The most important thing I learned (for me) was to bottom water – set the trays that the seedlings are in into a bigger tray without holes, and pour water in it. This prevents damping off, where the little seedlings get a fungus and die.” She also suggests running a fan in the room to help keep the soil surface dry and the air circulating.

Seed Starting

One setup from Community member steve232_NC

Don’t transplant too soon. Charlene warns, “When a seed germinates, its first 2 leaves often don’t resemble their true leaves at all. I usually transplant when they have 4 to 6 leaves.” Karen (luvmyb_b) agrees: ” When I first began seed starting, I didn’t realize the first two leaves that show up aren’t their true leaves. A beginner really should be told about this.” You want to give your new seedlings room to stretch their roots, but once again, you don’t need a fancy setup. Leroy (hopscotch) says, “As the seedlings get large enough, I transplant them into styrofam cups, Each cup is marked with a code so I know what is in them. For instance, C means Coleus, P means Pentas, RZ means Red Zinnia, and so on.”

Starting Seeds

Learn to “harden off”. As the seedlings get bigger and the weather gets warmer, you may be tempted to stick your new plants right into the soil. But there’s an important step you don’t want to skip, called “hardening off.” Charlene explains, “Harden off means to slowly introduce them to real sun, wind, and other elements that they will need to endure to live outdoors.” Leroy uses this method: “As the weather got warmer, the flats with all the cups and their seedlings went out onto the back deck. They started out there in the shade to get them used to the brighter light and different temperatures. I’ve had to move them inside a few times because of frost on a few nights. Gradually, those that grow in sun were moved out further into the sun and finally all the way there.”

Starting Seeds

Other Great Tips:

  • wilderness_NY_Z4 offers, “I think planning is the key to success. Don’t start too big or you will be overwhelmed. Be sure you start some seed that are very easy to grow. When I am getting discouraged with the way things are going I usually start a few marigolds as I know they will start and grow fast. It lifts my spirits and confidence.” I completely agree; see my previous posts on starting sunflowers, marigolds, and zinnias. She also recommends keeping a journal documenting your dates started, method used, germination date, and final product. This will help you in years ahead.
  • MDGreenery says, “I think labeling your seedlings is pretty important. It may seem like an obvious thing to do but often gets overlooked; I have been guilty of this myself, on more than one occasion. When I do remember to use my label sticks & markers; I usually include the plant’s name and the date I planted the seed on the label.”
  • Gayle (cove2700) reminds you stick with it. “Do not be frustrated & give up if something doesn’t grow. It happens to everybody. Just jump back in and try again. The same thing doesn’t always work for everybody so if one way doesn’t work out for you try another. It’s just a matter of getting the basics and go from there.”

Still have questions or feeling a little apprehensive? Come ask these experts (and many more) your questions directly. Our Gardening forum is very active, and our Community members would love to help you get the “seed-starting addiction”! Click here to visit the Gardening forum and join in.

  1. Wilderness_NY-Z4 says

    Jill great job. I do hope some of the readers will join in on the gardening forum. The folks there are friendly and anxious to answer questions and give help.

  2. Nick says

    I have tried saving marigold and Zinnia seeds from previous year’s plants and haven’t had much success. Any suggestions?

    • says

      Unfortunallly saving seeds could be frustating since not all are’prime’ and the results are not what you want , you are better off buying good seeds .

  3. says

    The last few years were not so successful with seed planting, flower or veggie, including seeds saved from various flowers in my garden. Very frustrating, as I spend more buying seedlings each Spring.

    • says

      From people that grow tomatoes for a living I learned that you loose quality from the seeds in your garden .I know this because I buy in bulk for them every season.

  4. Mona Brandt says

    I would like to join but I never can load your sites. What’s the problem? I have a new computer and it just loads and loads and nothing happens. The sites I am talking about is your forums and any of the others.

  5. Starting Lisianthus from seed says

    Please can someone tell me how the get Lisianthus to grow from seeds. Two years ago they did great but this year I have tried everything I know and cannot get them to grow! I’m wondering if I’m getting bad seeds. I’ve ordered from three different catalogues and no success! Need some help please. I’ve read articles on the internet too and on seed packets! Thanks for any help!

    • Grandmaof2Grandmaof2 says

      This is my first year trying lisianthus and they are growing, but soooo s l o w l y. I am trying them after seeing so many beautiful photos on the Garden forum. You can get some good advice there. Are they just not sprouting, or are they growing too slowly or damping off?

Add a Comment

Want more garden tips for your backyard?

Get ideas and advice for a beautiful landscape with our free Gardening newsletter!

Enter your email address: